How it works
The Commander deck clash tool analyzes two or more Magic: The Gathering decks head-to-head. Paste your deck URLs (from Moxfield, Archidekt, or MTGGoldfish) and the tool fetches each decklist, enriches every card with Scryfall data, and calculates all relevant metrics: power score (1–10), bracket (1–5), mana curve, ramp, card draw, removal, tutors, fast mana, combos, and game changers. Results are displayed in a side-by-side comparison table, and each deck receives heuristic-generated strengths and weaknesses.
Each deck is scored using the same 7-factor weighted system from the individual analyzer: fast mana (×3), tutors (×2), average mana value, interaction (×1.5), combo density (×5), extra turns/stax (×2), and card draw (×1). The raw score is normalized to a 1–10 scale. The clash tool automatically identifies which deck leads in each metric and awards an overall winner. Perfect for virtual playtesting, settling debates with friends, or deciding which deck to bring to your next Commander game night.
- Compare up to 4 Commander decks at the same time
- Detailed metric-by-metric comparison table with highlighted winner
- Same scoring system as the individual Rate My Decks analyzer
- Heuristic-generated strengths and weaknesses for each deck
- Support for Moxfield, Archidekt, and MTGGoldfish
- Automatic bracket and salt level detection (low / medium / high / very_high)